Our Kitchen
How to Decide What to Order When You Want To Try Something New at a Bedminster Restaurant
By The Bedminster Tavern

Quick answer: When you want to try something new at a restaurant, don't simply choose the dish with the most unfamiliar ingredients. Look for something that gives you one or two points of familiarity, then ask what makes the dish distinctive. Consider the preparation, seasonality, the restaurant's strengths, and what you already enjoy. Being adventurous works better when curiosity has a little context.
- You don't have to order the strangest thing on the menu to be adventurous.
- Start with flavors, ingredients, or preparations you already know you enjoy.
- Ask useful questions about how a dish tastes and is prepared, not simply "Is it good?"
- Seasonal dishes and specials can be good places to explore.
- Unfamiliar culinary terms become less intimidating once you understand what they mean for the actual eating experience.
- Sometimes the best way to discover a restaurant is to order what seems most expressive of its point of view.
- Why is ordering something new harder than it sounds?
- What's wrong with asking "Is it good?"
- How can you tell whether you'll probably like an unfamiliar dish?
- Should you order the restaurant's signature dish?
- Are specials a good place to try something new?
- How should you handle unfamiliar menu language?
- Should you ask your server what to order?
- What if an ingredient sounds strange?
- When should you take a bigger risk?
- How can you become a more adventurous diner?
- Frequently Asked Questions
The Problem With "I'll Try Anything"
There are two kinds of adventurous diners.
The first sees an unfamiliar ingredient and thinks:
That sounds interesting.
The second sees the same ingredient and thinks:
Absolutely not.
Most of us are somewhere in between.
We like discovering food, but we also recognize a basic truth about restaurants:
You only get one dinner.
Ordering something new involves a small amount of risk.
Choose well and you discover a dish, ingredient, or preparation you might order for years.
Choose poorly and you spend the next hour watching someone across the table enjoy exactly what you almost ordered.
Fortunately, adventurous dining doesn't have to mean ordering blindly.
There is a better way.
Stop Asking "Is It Good?"
This may be the least useful question you can ask a server when trying new food at Bedminster Tavern, or really anywhere.
Not because the server doesn't know the menu.
Because "good" tells them almost nothing about you.
Imagine asking:
"Is the fish good?"
What should the answer be?
"No, we were hoping nobody would notice"?
A more useful question gives the person helping you something to work with.
Try:
"Is this dish rich or lighter?"
"How spicy is it?"
"Is the sauce more savory or sweet?"
"Which dish would you choose if you wanted something seasonal?"
"I usually like ____. Which of these would you steer me toward?"
"What makes this dish different?"
Now you are having a useful conversation.
The goal isn't to ask someone else to decide what you like.
It is to give them enough information to help you make a better decision.
Start With One Thing You Know
Trying something new does not require abandoning everything familiar.
In fact, familiarity can be the bridge.
Suppose you know you love:
Mushrooms.
Steak.
Roasted vegetables.
Shellfish.
Bright citrus flavors.
Rich sauces.
Spicy food.
Crispy textures.
Use that information.
Instead of looking for a dish where you recognize every word, look for one where something you already enjoy leads you somewhere new.
Maybe you know the protein but not the preparation.
Maybe you know the vegetable but have never tasted that variety.
Maybe the cooking technique is familiar but the ingredient isn't.
Maybe you recognize almost everything except the sauce.
That is often the sweet spot.
You're not ordering the same thing again.
But you're also not playing culinary roulette.
Read the Verbs, Not Just the Nouns
People tend to scan menus for ingredients when deciding what to order at our Bedminster restaurant.
Chicken.
Salmon.
Beef.
Mushrooms.
Potatoes.
But the verbs can tell you just as much about what you're going to eat.
Roasted.
Braised.
Grilled.
Seared.
Poached.
Pickled.
Charred.
Cured.
Those words describe what happened to the ingredient.
And what happened to it often determines:
Texture
Intensity
Richness
Moisture
Browning
Acidity
How familiar the dish will feel
If you understand the preparation, an unfamiliar ingredient becomes considerably less mysterious.
A vegetable you've never tried before may seem like a bigger leap until you learn that it is roasted until caramelized and served with flavors you already love.
The menu just became easier to read.
Learn to Translate Restaurant Language Into Eating
Menus occasionally assume everyone attended culinary school.
You didn't.
You shouldn't need to.
The useful question when you encounter an unfamiliar term is:
What will that mean when I eat it?
A few examples:
Braised
Cooked slowly with moisture until the ingredient becomes tender.
What that means to you: usually softer texture and developed, savory flavor.
Confit
Traditionally, something cooked slowly in fat. The term is also used more broadly for slow-cooked preparations.
What that means to you: think richness and tenderness rather than a specific flavor.
Crudo
Raw fish or seafood prepared with seasonings such as oil, citrus, or other accompaniments.
What that means to you: fresh, delicate, uncooked.
Purée
An ingredient blended until smooth.
What that means to you: texture changes dramatically even if the ingredient is familiar.
Pickled
Preserved or quickly treated with an acidic solution.
What that means to you: expect acidity, brightness, and often some crunch.
You do not need to memorize a culinary dictionary.
Ask.
A good restaurant should be able to explain its food without making you feel as though you're taking an exam.
Don't Confuse Unfamiliar With Challenging
This distinction can make dining much more fun.
An ingredient can be unfamiliar to you and still have a flavor profile you immediately enjoy.
Likewise, a familiar ingredient can be prepared in a way that challenges your preferences.
The name of the ingredient is only one piece of information.
Ask about:
Flavor
Is it mild, earthy, sweet, bitter, smoky, acidic?
Texture
Is it tender, crisp, chewy, creamy?
Preparation
Is it raw, roasted, braised, grilled?
Role
Is it the centerpiece of the dish or a small accent?
That last question is especially useful.
Trying an unfamiliar ingredient as one element of a composed dish is very different from ordering an entire plate centered around it.
You can explore gradually.
There are no medals for culinary bravery.
Should You Order the Restaurant's "Signature" Dish?
Maybe.
But don't assume the dish everyone talks about is automatically the best dish for you when deciding what to order.
For a visitor to The Bedminster Tavern, a better question might be:
"What dish best represents the kitchen right now?"
That wording leaves room for seasonality.
It leaves room for something new.
It leaves room for the kitchen to evolve.
A restaurant with a strong culinary point of view should have more to say than one famous plate.
At The Bedminster Tavern, Executive Chef Christopher Albrecht's Farm-to-Fork philosophy emphasizes seasonality, thoughtful sourcing, ingredient quality, relationships with farmers and producers, and classical technique.
That makes "right now" an especially useful question.
What's interesting today may not be exactly what was most interesting three months ago.
Are Specials a Good Place to Take a Chance?
They can be.
A special may exist because:
An ingredient is particularly good.
Something became available in limited quantity.
The chef wanted to explore an idea.
The kitchen is highlighting something seasonal.
But "special" does not automatically mean "better."
The useful question is:
Why is it a special?
That's much more interesting.
If the answer is essentially:
"We got something excellent and wanted to cook it,"
you've learned something.
And if you like the ingredient or preparation, you may have just found the thing to order.
Ask What the Kitchen Is Excited About
This is different from asking:
"What's most popular?"
Popularity tells you what other diners order.
That's useful information, but it doesn't necessarily tell you what is interesting about the restaurant.
Try asking:
"What is the kitchen excited about right now?"
Now the conversation changes.
Maybe a seasonal ingredient just arrived.
Maybe there's a new dish.
Maybe a familiar item is prepared in a way you wouldn't expect.
Maybe the answer is still the restaurant's most popular dish.
That's fine too.
You're simply asking a better question.
Don't Let the Most Expensive Dish Make the Decision for You
Price creates expectations.
When people are celebrating or want a "good dinner," they sometimes assume the most expensive entrée must represent the highest expression of the kitchen.
It doesn't necessarily work that way.
Ingredient cost influences menu price.
So do preparation, portion, sourcing, and other operational realities.
A less expensive dish may involve exactly the kind of cooking you find most interesting.
If you want to understand the chef's point of view, price is not a reliable shortcut.
Read the dish.
Ask questions.
Then decide.
What If You Don't Know Whether You'll Like an Ingredient?
Say so.
This is where specificity helps.
Instead of:
"I've never had this. Is it weird?"
try:
"I've never had this. What does it taste like?"
Or:
"What would you compare the texture to?"
Or:
"Is that flavor prominent in the dish?"
Those questions are answerable.
"Weird" is personal.
One person's challenging ingredient is another person's Tuesday lunch.
Know Your Actual Dealbreakers
Adventurous dining works better when you know where you're not adventurous.
Maybe you strongly dislike:
Very bitter flavors.
Raw seafood.
Heavy smoke.
Intense heat.
Certain textures.
Very rich dishes.
That's useful information.
You don't need to overcome every preference in order to become a curious diner.
The objective is not to prove something.
It's to expand the range of things you enjoy.
There is a big difference between:
"I've never tried that."
and:
"I know I don't enjoy that."
Pay attention to which one you're saying.
Share When You Want to Explore More
Dining with other curious people gives you an advantage:
You don't have to commit an entire meal to every discovery.
Sharing can let the table explore more.
An unfamiliar appetizer becomes much less intimidating when four people are tasting it.
Two entrées with different preparations can become a conversation.
A side dish nobody has tried becomes something everyone gets to experience.
This is one reason restaurants can be particularly good environments for culinary discovery.
You are not simply feeding yourself.
You are sharing an experience.
Let Seasonality Make Some Decisions for You
One of the easiest ways to get out of an ordering rut is to stop asking:
"What do I always get?"
and ask:
"What makes sense right now?"
Seasonality provides a natural filter.
It narrows the possibilities.
It gives the kitchen ingredients to respond to.
And it creates a reason for your restaurant habits to change throughout the year.
This doesn't mean you need to understand agricultural calendars.
When deciding what to order for dinner at The Bedminster Tavern, ask the server:
"What's particularly seasonal right now?"
That's enough.
Sometimes the Simplest Dish Tells You the Most
There is another trap adventurous diners fall into:
Assuming complexity equals sophistication.
More ingredients.
More components.
More unfamiliar words.
More technique visible on the plate.
Sometimes that's exciting.
Sometimes the better dish is the one where the chef knew when to stop.
Excellent ingredients can reward restraint.
Good technique can make simple food difficult to improve upon.
A dish doesn't need to make you decode it to be interesting.
Sometimes the most confident cooking is the least complicated.
How to Order Something New Without Regretting It
Here's the practical version.
1. Identify what you're in the mood for
Light? Rich? Savory? Fresh? Comforting?
2. Find one familiar anchor
An ingredient, flavor, or preparation you already enjoy.
3. Identify what is new
Is it the ingredient, preparation, sauce, or combination?
4. Translate unfamiliar terms
Ask what they mean for flavor and texture.
5. Ask one useful question
Not "Is it good?"
Ask something that helps the restaurant understand your preferences.
6. Consider what's seasonal
Especially when the restaurant's culinary philosophy emphasizes ingredients and seasonality.
7. Decide how much adventure you want tonight
There is a difference between exploring and gambling.
8. Order it
At some point, analysis has to end.
Dinner is getting cold.
Becoming a Better Diner Is a Lot Like Becoming a Better Cook
Both require attention.
You notice what you like.
You learn why you like it.
You discover preparations.
You recognize ingredients.
You understand terms that once seemed obscure.
Your reference points multiply.
Eventually, menus become easier to read because you have more experiences to compare.
That is the real reward of trying new food.
It isn't being able to say you've eaten something unusual.
It's having more things in the world that you enjoy eating.
That's a pretty good return on curiosity.
Frequently Asked Questions
How do I choose something new from a restaurant menu?
Start with something you know you enjoy, then look for a dish that introduces one unfamiliar ingredient, preparation, or flavor. Ask how the dish tastes and is prepared before deciding.
What should I ask a server when I don't know what to order?
Describe what you're in the mood for or what you normally enjoy. Questions about flavor, texture, richness, spice, preparation, or seasonality are generally more useful than simply asking what's "good."
Should I order the most popular dish at a restaurant?
Popularity can be useful information, but it doesn't guarantee the dish matches your preferences. Consider asking what best represents the kitchen or what is particularly interesting right now.
Are restaurant specials worth ordering?
They can be. Ask why the dish is being offered as a special. Seasonal availability, an excellent ingredient, or a new culinary idea can all be good reasons.
How can I understand unfamiliar words on a restaurant menu?
Ask what the term means for the eating experience. Understanding whether something is raw, braised, pickled, grilled, rich, crisp, tender, or acidic is often more useful than memorizing culinary terminology.
Is seasonal food a good choice when I want to try something new?
It can be. Seasonal ingredients give chefs opportunities to work with food that is particularly relevant at that time of year and can help diners move beyond their usual choices.
What if I order something new and don't like it?
Not every experiment becomes a favorite. Pay attention to what you didn't enjoy, such as the flavor, texture, ingredient, or preparation. That knowledge can help you make better choices next time.
About The Bedminster Tavern
The Bedminster Tavern is a neighborhood gathering place at 285 Main Street in Bedminster, New Jersey.
Executive Chef Christopher Albrecht leads a Farm-to-Fork culinary philosophy centered on seasonality, thoughtful sourcing, ingredient quality, relationships with farmers and producers, and classical technique.
That philosophy gives curious diners a simple question worth asking:
What's interesting right now?
Try Something You Haven't Tried Before
The next time you visit The Bedminster Tavern, you don't need to order blindly.
Ask a question.
Explore an unfamiliar preparation.
Try something seasonal.
Share something you've never had.
Or simply order the dish that made you stop reading the menu for a second.
Explore dining at The Bedminster Tavern for current menu information.
For Chef Christopher stories, culinary classes, seasonal updates, and what's happening around the Tavern, join The Bedminster Tavern email list.
Join the email list for more from the Tavern.
